Tuesday, March 3, 2009

My Piano Keys --- Her Mom is NOT White (& Neither Is Her Dad)


I'd say my complexion is caramel.

My wife's complexion is that of a perfectly fried French fry.

My son's coloring is a bit richer than mine, almost Aboriginal in the way it glows all year long.

My daughter's skin is the color of parchment (faint parchment at that) or maybe that paper color, Ivory Linen.

My mother and father's complexion is about the same, a shade lighter than mine.

My maternal grandparents both had dark brown complexions.

My paternal grandmother's skin was golden and her hair was like silver silk. My paternal grandfather was brown-skinned.

During my recent trip home to Chi-Town, I visited my great aunt (my paternal grandmother's sister) on the occasion of her 97th birthday. Her skin was white and she wore her hair pulled back into one silver braid that ran down the length of her back.

And until I was informed otherwise as a high schooler, I just knew one of my cousin's fathers was Jewish.

And why do I point out all of this frivolous information?

Because for whatever reason for people of color, complexion matters. If I wanted this post to run very, very long, I could provide my reasons for why people believe this matters, and how it's been used to divide, similar to religion, political beliefs and nationality. But I only want it to run kind of long, so I won't.

Coming from Chicago I was exposed to African Americans of all skin colors. My first exposure to this was in my own family where from one family member to the next, complexion jumped from one end to the other of the color spectrum. And hair texture? When I was little, for the life of me I didn't understand why everyone on my father's side had straight, wavy or curly hair without the aid of a beauty salon or hair care products. To this day, my father's hair blows in the wind like a flag and he could care less. Sadly, I grew up believing if you were African American you had "coarse" hair and if you didn't it was either because you a) pressed the hell out of it with a hot comb, or b) had a Jheri curl. Even more pathetic, I was jealous that my father had the head of hair he did. I thought something was wrong with me because that didn't pass on to me (even though it did just before my hair fell out). So what did I do, I spent the better part of my teenage years brushing jars of grease into my head to get one or two waves to pop. I collected lint everywhere I went and wearing a hat was just disgusting.

But by the time I was a teenager, I understood that we (African Americans) took on many appearances. From my father's mother who could've easily passed for white and passed on passing to live a life of discrimination, to my mother's side and their unmistakable African characteristics: wide, flat (and proud) noses, strong (some would argue large) foreheads and brown skin.

Out East things are a bit different. I can't tell you how many times I've been told who is or is not African American because their hair is curly, or they have a fair complexion. My wife suffered through this growing up being told she must've been something else besides African American. Years ago, a workout partner told me a woman he was dating had to be Spanish.

"Why?" I asked.

"Because her hair is curly," he said.

"And that makes her not black?" I asked incredulously.

I laughed hysterically as he continued to dig a hole for himself with his teeth.

So now I'm a father. When I'm with my daughter I'm sometimes asked not if my wife is white, but if she's not black or of mixed race.

My daughter is a dead ringer for my father and when they're together she looks more like his child than mine and more like her daughter than I do his son. To the questioner, I laugh politely and say no. Only upon someone's insistence do I become a bit sharp with my "no." But as each time I'm asked is an opportunity to educate, I typically try to explain that BLACK PEOPLE COME IN ALL COLORS AND NONE OF US ARE ACTUALLY "BLACK".

The only time this foolishness is even more infuriating is when a person of color does the same thing. Last year after attending a god-awful play with my son at his school, I was standing in the lobby with my daughter while I waited for him to finish socializing. An African American woman looked at the two of us and shot me the dirty looks. I knew exactly what she was thinking. She looked perplexed when my son returned to us and was completely stunned when my wife joined us after using the ladies' room. During a Take Your Kids To Work day at my wife's job she encountered the same thing. "Is your husband white?" an African American co-worker asked, and when my son called out to her, this woman was completely confused too.

At the end of the day it's nobody's business what you or your children "are." At the end of the day who cares? At the end of the day complexion does not determine beauty or "niceness" and if it does for you, then you've got a problem.

Sometimes interracial marriage is a factor, but in cases like my family's, it is not. For anyone who is curious, people in my family (or anyone's African American family) stretch the color spectrum as do my two kids (my piano keys) because of a little thing called a gene pool. Take any grade school health class and they explain it there.

18 Holler Backs:

Nerd Girl said...

It is unbelievable to me that color - and hair - are still such issues in our community. Seems like by now everyone should realize that our gene pools are deep and you never know what combination will materialize!

My mom is fair, my dad is brown. Two of us are brown, two are fair. We are in our 20s and 30s - people still ask us if we have the same parents. Sigh.

My daughter, born of two people who couldn't be mistaken for anything but black, has wavy hair. If one more person asks me what she's mixed with I'm going to formulate an answer that's not nearly as nice as my current which is "her father and I."

I have a relative who is still upset - nearly 10 years later - that her daughter is "so black." And while I pray she doesn't jack her daughter's self esteem because of her own color issues, really, I know that in all likelihood she already has.

I guess hair and color issues will continue to be a part of our "legacy" for at least another couple hundred years.

Anonymous said...

Wow! That's really crazy. People are so ignorant and really bold to even verbalize the stupiod thoughts they have. Just WOW!

Quiskaeya said...

It is sad that in our current age and times that color is such a source of contention in our community. Even in the caribbean color is an issue although it's more apparent in our class "caste" system.

I have children who are biracial and interestingly enough wrote a similar post on why Mama doesn't look like baby. Even though my children are mixed, I have a lot of family & friends who aren't and one could never tell their ethnicity at first contact.

Rachel said...

Great post! I am a new reader and fan - saw you over at BlackandMarriedwithKids.com.

As a brown woman with curly hair I encounter these questions all the time, and surprisingly it is usually from other Brown people! Some will argue or get indignant when they say what are you mixed with and I say "black and African-American" or they ask me what kind of hair I bought and I tell them I didn't.

The most surprising exchange was when a white woman asked me what products I used because she wanted to wear her natural curls without frizz. I was totally shocked by that one...

One thing I am pleased to see, is that more and more Black women are becoming curious about what their natural hair texture is. So many of us had relaxers at an early age that we don't know we have curls underneath!

Perhaps the more of us who rock our varying textures of hair, the less perplexing it will be for others that yes, Black people do come with alot of variety. Or, maybe it will just confuse them more!

Urban Thought said...

You're right... It isn't anyone's business who is what and what ever race/heritage/background.

That being said... I've come across some situations where it isn't just black people who focus on the color of ones skin to pass judgment. Indians (those of the Asian persuasion), Hispanics and a couple of other groups I've come across do the same exact thing. It's really sad that we are stuck on skin color when character speaks volumes.

E. Payne said...

Everyone - Amen to all of your comments. They all speak volumes. Glad to know I'm not the only one.

Anonymous said...

Good post E. I guess I'm not surprised by what you've experienced. When I was younger and did have hair, because it wasn't coarse it was always assumed that I was not Black, but either Latino or Indian. Black was always the last guess and was always followed up with, "Well you must be mixed". Despite the fact I am half Chinese I was always amused by the assumption I that I had to be of mixed descent because my hair was straight.

Interestingly enough, now that I no longer have hair I am never mistaken for anything else but Black. Go figure.

Peace,
Ken

Wenylla said...

Funny our focus on complexion....and hair texture....interesting to know that men have hair issues too.

Latinegro said...

Wow...you brought me back to may days in school when I felt I had to explain that my light skinned father was truley my father. I feel the need to be like...my mother is really dark.

It sucks to be told that you have bad hair. My mother would tell me I ended up with my grandfathers hair and of course my aunts would joke about how rough is hair was. Nappy is a word often used by my family.

So, as you see...Latinos also come in all colors but only the darker ones seem to get rediculed about about how dark they are or how bad our hair is.

Great post E

Harriet said...

When Jesus went back to His hometown, He marvelled and was in awe...not that the people there were so receptive, but at their unbelief.

These days, I marvel at the ignorance of otherwise intelligent people when it comes to color. I grew up in a military environment, and it didn't matter what your color was...there was a conglomerate of EVERYTHING in school!

Either way, it's really disappointing. I celebrate the beauty of your family, though! Everyone else can kiss your grits. LOL

Brooke said...

This topic seems to always pop up. I even blogged about good and bad hair and skin color once. It amazes me the ignorance some of us...A LOT of us...have - both black and white.

People used to ask my sister and I all the time if we had the same dad. I guess since we lived together they automatically knew we had the same mom. My sister is fairer than I am, but only by maybe 2-3 shades, nothing drastic. Yet because she has long, wavy hair and I don't, we must automatically have a different father even though some say we look exactly alike.

What I also find interesting, especially since moving to NYC, is that Africans think I'm African, Dominicans think I'm Dominican, Jamaicans think I'm Jamaican, etc. People see what they want to see. When asked, I simply say I'm black. Who wants to run down their family tree all the time? Sure, I could say "well, my paternal great-grandfather was a German Jew who married an Ethiopian woman, my maternal great-grandmother was half Italian and half French Creole who married a man from Martinique." We'd be here all day! I'm black, let's just leave it at that. Why folks always seek to define you, simply because they're color struck, is beyond me.

E. Payne said...

@Brooke - funny! I hear you. I remember telling a Haitian guy I wasn't Haitian and I'll never forget him telling me, "You have the complexion for it." He was blue-black. Huh? Yeah if you go into a deep enough explanation (as you briefly did with your gene pool) then sure there may or may not be a reason for your variances from one black person to the next, but then here's another thought. What makes them so "Black" to give them the authority to question you? Coarse hair? No "distinct" features? I think these individuals have the bigger issues. And as far as those of other ethnicities willing to question yours, well that's just ignorant, presumptive, insulting, prejudiced and rude to insinuate that you "must be something else," or "must be something more" if you have straight to wavy hair, light eyes or a lighter complexion, and even worse to put a child in a box like this, when they could truly care less. The wife and I will and have done everything in our power to prevent our kids from growing up colorstruck or subscribing to its "isms."

By the way, Brooke - you're Number One on the Top Commenters list!

Wifey said...

It kills me that someone would actually ask another person that. I had someone ask me "what I was" once. And it always made me more mad when another black person questioned me.

When my daughter was born the nurse that checked me in the hospital had my race listed as "other" on my chart. When shifts changed the new nurse asked me to confirm that I was indeed a black woman so she could change the chart. After a good laugh at the first nurses expense, my daughter was born 6 hours later. She was a bright lightskin child with blond hair. I wonder what they checked on her box.

Winks & Smiles,
Wifey

Brooke said...

The blond hair probably threw everyone for a loop! I'll be curious to see what my nephew's go thru. My sister's husband is from Morocco, yet everyone assumes he's Italian. Why? Cuz he has an olive complexion and owns a pizza shop. Just silly.

Once someone asked my 5 year nephew "what he was"...and he said "5" :)

Then they said, "no, what color are you?" and he said "beige." I couldn't believe it when my sister told me that...and this was asked of him at SCHOOL by ANOTHER PARENT!!! She promptly told this other parent about herself and kept it moving. The nerve of some people...just plain ignorant.

Husband Land said...

Wow - I must have been living in a cave somewhere. As a "white" guy, I didn't know this was a such a hot topic in the African-Amerian community. I'm a bit ashamed to admit it, but its true.

Thanks for the education.

Love your stuff
-Al

E. Payne said...

Husband Land aka Al - thanks for your comment and for visiting. Welcome. Hope you'll stick around!

Adiam said...

Wow Wow Wow...I know I am little late on this one. People never fail to amaze me. This is one of the most annoying questions I get asked in the US " Are you black?" I'll never get it. My origins are in Eritrea ( East Africa ) but for most of my life I was raised in Germany.In Europe the question whether I was black was never asked..it was more " how do you comb your hair, how often do you wash it, how come your cousin has a darker shade than you, do you tan in the sun, ever get sunburned, when are you going back to Africa, do you speak African...bla bla bla". It was pretty obvious that I was black..as matter of fact there might have been numerous times as an only black child in elementary school I wished I wasn't..sad but true. You think black people in the States are a minority..please.The first time I moved to the US I was proud and happy to see what we as Black people were able to accomplish and all the opportunities we had to move forward. Black TV, Black Magazines..boy I felt like I was spoken to for the first time in my life. Don't get me wrong, growing up in Germany after all was a blessing, and it will always be my home, besides my orginal home. The issues I ecountered as a black woman were never addressed in a country that had no significant history of black people. To make a long story short. I am still amazed by the people ( mostly blacks) who ask me if I am black...every time I get asked that questions all I want to say is " last time I checked in the mirror I was". Mind you but where I am from, it does not matter if you are black Dominican, black Jamaican, black African or African American ( I hear on this one Brooke)..if I look at you and you are obviously of a black race, you are black-period.- and yes I do agree Eric that we are all mixed.I had this girl at CVS argue with me that my hair was too good for me to be black, even after I gave her a 20 min lecture about being from Africa & both of my parents are black and I am not mixed.Another time, some Haitian girls were telling my cousin and I that we can't be Africans because we simply don't look like Africans? I asked how Africans look like in their opinion...didn't get an answer. Makes me wonder of the picture we have of ourselves. So I wonder what do they really mean when they ask me if I am black? I can't help but wonder if African Americans are claiming being Black only for African Americans? I don't know but my good friend who is African American still can't grasp the fact that I am black because I look spanish to her? To set the record straight, am I African American? No. Am I Black? HELL YES and proud of it! It's 2009, we finally have a black President in the United States, there are millions of black people that exist outside of the US and Africa, we do come in all shades, shapes and hair types, some of us speak English, some of us Dutch, German,Tigrinya,Swahili,French,Creole etc and I love it. It's about time we learn, understand and appreciate our diverseness. Only if we love ourselves and teach the same our children will we continue to succeed. Word of advice, stop calling coarse hair bad, and silky hair good..it's the simple things we do and say in our every day lives that make the biggest impact! And I did want to make a long story short...hmmm ~ moi

Leslie said...

Wow!! Great post! Adiam and Brooke said it best. Im the one always getting the "good hair" comment. Uggghhhh, just makes me sick. Especially when I went back to embracing my natural hair. God made no mistakes when created each and every one of us. My family is Black, Jamaican, & Panamanian. Yet at the end of the day Im black and so is my daughter.

We must embrace the different flavors we come in when it comes to hair and complexion.